Tuesday, November 17, 2026

Two FOODLAB Logo Marks are Confusable for Various Food Services, Says TTAB

The Board affirmed a refusal to register the FOODLAB logo mark shown first below, for "Concession stands featuring food and food kiosks at dining facilities of colleges and universities' (in International Class 35) and "Cafeteria services; contract food and beverage services; restaurant and catering services; food preparation services; carryout restaurant services; self-service restaurant services; providing of food and drink for consumption on and off the premises, all of which are offered at dining facilities of colleges and universities" (Class 43), concluding that confusion is likely with the registered mark shown second below, for, inter alia, restaurant services. In re Aramark Services, Inc., Serial No. 99102928 (November 12, 2026) [not precedential] (Opinion by Judge Mark A. Thurmon).

The Marks: The Board found the word FOODLAB to the be the dominant element in both marks. They are similar in sound because few consumers will pronounce or attempt to describe the design elements in the marks. "Consumers familiar with the cited mark, are likely to believe the applied-for mark is just a shortened version of the cited mark, thus creating the same or a very similar commercial impression."

The Services: As to Applicant Aramark's Class 43 services, its "restaurant and catering services" are in-part identical to the registrant's "restaurant services." Aramark argued that its application "only covers services offered at dining facilities of colleges and universities." Not true, said the Board, because "restaurant and catering services' are a distinct entry in the identification, separated by a semicolon, and one that includes no limitation. 'Under standard examination practice, a semicolon is used to separate distinct categories of goods or services.'" Monster Energy Co. v. Lo, No. 91225050, 2023 TTAB LEXIS 14, at *20 n.35 (TTAB 2023). [Seems to be a rather harsh and unrealistic reading of the phrase "all of which are offered at dining facilities of colleges and universities" - ed.].

In any case, even if Aramark's restaurant services are so limited, they still are a sub-set of, and are encompassed by, registrant's restaurant services.

Turning to Aramark's Class 35 services, Examining Attorney Collier L. Johnson II provided evidence that third parties often offer both restaurant services and concession stand or food kiosks businesses under a single mark, including at a college or university.

Moreover, the Board found that the services overlap on their faces. "[W]e find Applicant’s concession stands are a type of restaurant, and that Applicant’s Class 35 services are identical in part to the restaurant services identified in the cited registration. The fact that Applicant’s services are limited to colleges and universities is of no import here for the reasons given above. Applicant has again identified services that are a subset of the services identified in the cited registration (i.e., these services are identical in part)."

Quite simply, the Class 35 and Class 43 services identified in the application are identical in part or highly related to the services identified in the cited registration. This fact increases the likelihood of confusion. The second DuPont factor supports the Section 2(d) refusal.

Channels of Trade: The Board presumed that the services that are identical in-part will all pass through the college and university food service trade channels and will be offered to the same class of purchasers. In re Viterra Inc., 671 F.3d 1358, 1362 (Fed. Cir. 2012). In any case, the evidence showed that the trade channels and consumers overlap.

Conceptual Weakness of the Cited Mark: The Board reviewed Aramark's evidence of third-party registrations for marks containing the word "LAB" for restaurant and related services, but none of the registrations included the words FOOD LAB. The Board concluded that these registrations did not show any conceptual weakness in the cited mark.

The university evidence shows that a “food lab” is an understood concept. It is a laboratory for food, a place to do some type of scientific work relating to food. But that understanding is quite broad and could include anything from recipe formulation to work on food chemistry. There is no evidence showing that consumers believe the words “Food Lab” have any particular meaning when used in connection with restaurant services.

Actual Confusion: Aramark argued that confusion is unlikely “because there has been no apparent confusion” despite about five years of coexistence. The Board was unmoved: "If we had evidence showing that these two marks coexisted in the same geographic region and served the same types of consumers within that region, we could evaluate whether there was meaningful coexistence without confusion." But there was no such evidence.

Conclusion: The first, second, and third DuPont factors supported the refusal. The rest were either neutral or irrelevant. And so, the Board upheld the refusal.

Read comments and post your comment here.

TTABlogger comment: Is this a WYHA??

Text Copyright John L. Welch 2026.

0 Comments:

Post a Comment

<< Home