Friday, November 20, 2026

TTABlog Test: Is SANTA ANA for Coffee Confusable with SANTA ANA SWEETS for Chocolate Covered Caramels?

Here we go with a test of my proposition that coffee is related to all food items, at least at the TTAB. The USPTO refused to register the mark SANTA ANA for "coffee," deeming confusion likely with the registered mark SANTA ANA SWEETS for "chocolate confections, namely, chocolate covered caramels" [SWEETS disclaimed]. The marks are certainly too close, but what about the goods? In re Farmer Bros. Co., Serial No. 98848559 (November 18, 2026) [Not precedential] (Opinion by Judge Thomas W. Wellington).

The Marks: "Although the SWEETS term is not entirely removed from our consideration in comparing the marks, it plays a significantly less important role in distinguishing them. * * * SANTA ANA is therefore the sole or predominant source-identifying element of the registered mark."

There was no dispute that SANTA ANA has geographical significance. Applicant Farmer Bros. pointed out that the registrant is based in Santa Ana, California. The Examining Attorney Sarah O. Frizalone maintained that the marks "create the same impression of the hot dry winds from the desert region of California." The Board found that both marks may be perceived by consumers as conjuring the city or area of Santa Ana in California.

In sum, Applicant’s SANTA ANA mark and Registrant’s SANTA ANA SWEETS mark are very similar in appearance, sound, meaning and commercial impression. This factor therefore weighs in favor of finding confusion likely.

Strength of the Cited Mark: The Examining Attorney acknowledged that the cited registration issued under Section 2(f) but argued that even weak marks are entitled to protection under Section 2(d). The Board noted that the validity of the registration and its claim under Section 2(f) cannot be challenged here.

The Board found that the cited mark has some conceptual weakness based on geographical significance, but there was no evidence of third-party use of SANTA ANA for the involved goods that would weaken the mark's commercial strength. The Board therefore found that the fourth DuPont factor slightly favored the applicant.

The Goods: The Examining Attorney submitted ten third-party registrations covering coffee and chocolates, as well as excerpts from eight third-party websites "showing that the same entities commonly manufacture, market, and sell both coffee and confectionery chocolates, under the same mark."

Trade Channels and Consumers: The third-party website evidence demonstrated that the involved goods "may be encountered by the same classes of consumers under the same marks in common trade channels, namely, retail stores and websites providing Applicant’s coffee on the one hand, and Registrant’s chocolates on the other hand."

Conclusion: The Board found that the first, second and third DuPont factors outweighed the slight conceptual weakness of the cited mark, and so it upheld the refusal to register.

Read comments and post your comment here.

TTABlogger comment: Yep. As I said two days ago, coffee is related to just about every food item, at least in TTAB-land. BTW: the Santa Ana winds are also called the "devil winds," says Wikipedia.

Text Copyright John L. Welch 2026.

0 Comments:

Post a Comment

<< Home