Wednesday, November 18, 2026

TTABlog Test: Is CANAN KOSKA for Coffee Confusable with KOSKA for Candy, Honey, and Nut-Based Snacks?

The USPTO refused to register the mark CANAN KOSKA for "coffee," concluding that confusion is likely with the registered mark KOSKA for "jams; fruit paste; fruit preserves; seed-based snack foods; nut-based snack foods; tahini (sesame seed paste)" and "candy; halva; Turkish delight; molasses; honey; marzipan; wafers; nougat; chocolate; chocolate confections; candy mints; confectionery made of sugar." Applicant argued that the goods are not related and its mark would be perceived as the name of an individual. How do you think this came out? In re American Beauty Supply LLC, Serial No. 99139190 (November 16, 2026) [not precedential] (Opinion by Judge Rober Lavache).

The Goods: Examining Attorney Brandi Brenner provided evidence from third-party websites showing both coffee and one or more of registrant’s goods being offered by the same entity under the same mark: for example, Amazon.com offers coffee, candy, candy mints, chocolate, honey, tahini, nut-based snack foods, and fruit spread under the 365 BY WHOLE FOODS MARKET mark. She also submitted 26 active, use-based, third-party registrations covering coffee and various of registrant's goods. The Board found that the second DuPont factor supported the refusal.

Trade Channels and Consumers: The third-party evidence established that the respective goods are encountered by the same classes of consumers in the same channels of trade. And so, the third DuPont factor supported the refusal.

The Marks: The Board rejected applicant's argument that CANAN, as the first element in its mark, is the dominant element. "[B]oth terms appear to be arbitrary in connection with the goods. Thus, we find that the terms are entitled to equal weight when comparing Applicant’s mark to the cited mark."

However, our finding that neither term in Applicant’s mark is the dominant element does not dictate a conclusion that confusion is unlikely here, especially given that Applicant’s mark incorporates the entirety of the cited mark. And, as the Examining Attorney points out, the mere addition of a term to a registered mark may not be sufficient to avoid confusing similarity.

The Board found unpersuasive applicant's argument that the addition of CANAN to KOSKA changes the mark’s connotation and overall commercial impression because consumers would view the combination as an individual’s name.

Even if consumers would view Applicant’s mark as a person’s name, where CANAN is the first name and KOSKA is the surname, those same consumers could view the cited mark as consisting of just the surname portion of Applicant’s mark. In other words, consumers could reasonably assume that Registrant’s goods sold under the KOSKA mark are from the same source as the goods sold under Applicant’s CANAN KOSKA mark, and that the CANAN KOSKA mark is merely a variation or derivative of the KOSKA mark, or vice versa.

Moreover, applicant's mark is in standard characters and could displayed in a way that emphasizes the word KOSKA: for example, displaying it in a larger, bolder, or otherwise more distinctive typeface.

In sum, the Board found the marks to be similar in sound, appearance, connotation, and overall commercial impression, and therefore the first DuPont factor supported the refusal.

Purchaser Care: The Board must presume that the standard of care for purchasing decisions is that of the least sophisticated potential purchaser. See Stone Lion, 746 F.3d at 1325. Here, "the least sophisticated purchaser is a member of the general public who may have less knowledge about the goods and exercise less diligence in their purchasing decisions, especially where, as here, the goods can be relatively inexpensive." "In any event, even sophisticated purchasers are not immune from source confusion, especially where, as here, the goods are related and would be offered under similar marks."

The Board found the fourth DuPont factor to be neutral. [Seems like it supports the refusal - ed.]. It also found the seventh and eighth factors (actual confusion) to be neutral.

Conclusion: Confusion is likely, and so the Board affirmed the refusal.

Read comments and post your comment here.

TTABlogger comment: Is there any food item that, in TTAB-land, is not related to coffee? This mechanical approach to the DuPont factors shows why the deck is stacked against the applicant. Do you think there is confusion in the real world?

Text Copyright John L. Welch 2026.

0 Comments:

Post a Comment

<< Home