TTAB Finds Storage Cart Configuration Lacks Acquired Distinctiveness
The Board upheld a refusal to register the product configuration shown below, for “Carts; Mobile storage cart for domestic and commercial use” in International Class 12, and “Industrial work tables; Lockers; Metal storage cabinets; Storage racks; Storage shelves; Work benches” in International Class 20, finding that the proposed mark (which, under Wal-Mart, cannot be inherently distinctive) lacked acquired distinctiveness and therefore is unregistrable under Sections 1, 2, and 45 of the Trademark Act. In re Groves Incorporated, Inc., Serial No. 98373316 (November 13, 2026) [not precedential] (Opinion by Judge Mark Lebow).
Applicant Groves described the mark as "a three-dimensional configuration of a design feature of the identified goods in the nature of a panel comprising intersecting wires creating a cross-hatch pattern, with one set of wires arranged horizontally and one set of wires arranged at an angle to create a repeating pattern of parallelograms. The matter shown in broken or dotted lines is not part of the mark and serves only to show the position or placement of the mark."
The Board observed that the burden to prove acquired distinctiveness under Section 2(f) is heavier for a product configuration mark. See In re Ennco Displays Sys., No. 74439206, 2000 TTAB LEXIS 235, *3. "One reason for the heavy burden is that 'consumers do not associate the design of a product with a particular manufacturer as readily as they do a trademark or product packaging trade dress.'"
The relevant considerations are association of the product design with a source by actual purchasers, length and exclusivity of use, amount and manner of advertising, sales and number of customers, intentional copying, and unsolicited media coverage. Converse, Inc. v. Int’l Trade Comm’n, 909 F.3d 1110, 1120 (Fed. Cir. 2018).
Groves submitted the testimony affidavit of its president and nine affidavits from firefighters, two of whom were also distributors and one was a volunteer firefighter.
The affiants, who come from a small slice of the general public, are limited in number and do not address how the average purchaser of the identified goods perceives the design. Moreover, the classes of purchasers of the goods are not limited to firefighters.
Groves claimed use of the proposed mark since 2006. Examining Attorney Andrew Leaser pointed out that "even long exclusive use of a product is not sufficient to establish acquired distinctiveness." Applicant's catalog also offered goods in the same categories identified in its application, that use a square wire pattern rather than its diagonal design. "A design that Applicant itself does not use consistently across the identified goods is less likely to be perceived as indicating a single source for those goods than a design used consistently across the goods."
Groves claimed advertising expenditures of $100,000 to $150,000 a year, several million dollars over the life of the company, and attendance at about a dozen fire-industry trade shows a year. However, the advertising and promotional materials prominently featured the word mark READY RACK (and related logos) as the primary source identifier.
Advertising expenditures show effort. They do not show that the effort succeeded in causing purchasers to treat this panel as a mark. In re Boston Beer Co., 198 F.3d 1370, 1373 (Fed. Cir. 1999). More importantly, the materials do not direct purchasers to the configuration as an indication of source.
Groves argued that its distributors grew from about 173 in 2006 to more than 500 - which Groves characterized as more than half of the distributors serving about 30,000 fire departments - purportedly showing commercial success and market recognition. The Board was unmoved:
Distributor growth, standing alone, has little probative value on whether purchasers perceive this product design as a mark. While an increase in the number of distributors may reflect commercial success of the goods themselves, without sales data, pricing, or market context, the raw increase in distributors does not show that the relevant public has come to regard the “diagonal” wire pattern as indicating source.
There was no probative evidence of intentional copying. Several media articles referenced square and diagonal grid products as different product types, but they did not refer to the diagonal design as a trademark or source indicator.
The Board concluded that the evidence failed to establish acquired distinctiveness, and so it affirmed the refusal.
Read comments and post your comment here.
TTABlogger comment: Do you think that if the goods were limited to firehouse equipment, Groves might clear the Section 2(f) hurdle?
Text Copyright John L. Welch 2026.





0 Comments:
Post a Comment
<< Home